Friday, February 18, 2011

Ki Tisa - Understanding the golden calf

Do you remember being told about the sin of the Golden Calf in school? Put yourself back there, as an unassuming and unsophisticated (at least compared to now!) child. Try and picture the face of your teacher, and the pictures of the scene you saw in books or that you had in your head. Hear again the sounds of your class, or the sounds that might have been going on around the whole episode of the Golden Calf. Try to get back into the feeling you had - and perhaps the feelings the Bnei Yisrael had... and now STOP!

It's really hard to stop! It's hard to re-evaluate - especially things that we learn to vividly as children. So certainly and so simply!

One thing is for sure. The pictures that I have in my head, the ideas that I naturally have when I think of what happened that day at the foot of Har Sinai, is totally false. The way I was taught it (and probably the way you were) lacked any depth into the human psyche, human needs, desires, mistakes, and dare I say it, a lack of real understanding of the Torah. I don't blame my teachers, it's difficult to know how to teach children, with the knowledge that the true depths are so complex.

My assertion has always been that the Torah is meant for us to learn from, so let's look at what may have been going on and see if it is relevant to us.

The Jewish people had recently come out of Egypt via the miracles we know so well. They had crossed the sea, and had a 40 day miraculous existence in the desert, followed by an awesome prophetic experience where Hashem 'spoke' to them. Their lives turned upside down, there was one piece of certainty that they could hold on to.

This certainty was Moshe. The existence of G-d was obvious - He was all around them in so many ways. Yet the nature of the miracles was not that each person asked Hashem for anything and got it. Far from it. There was only one Jew who the people believed had the key to unlocking Hashem's powers. It was Moshe who had instigated the Exodus, it was Moshe through whom the plagues were manifested. And now Moshe was gone!

Human beings NEED certainty. (We also need some uncertainty, or we get bored - but that is a separate discussion!.) The definition of a need, is that without it, we wont survive. So human beings will do anything in order to fill one of their needs.

This 'neediness' can be seen in the way the Jews fervently went about arranging the calf. They took off the jewlery they were wearing, they even killed Chur as he tried to stop them. They had somehow been worked into a frenzy of need, and now they were unstoppable.

They were called a 'stiff necked people' - as the Ibn Exra points out, this is because stubborn people never looks back once he starts in a certain direction. Right now, they were stiff necked because they were heading down the path to the human need.

Human beings (all of us?) will igo against their values in order to fulfill a need. Does that make it okay? Certainly not. There are many ways that we can fulfill our needs, and they fall along a range of terribly negative to wonderfully positive.

I believe the key is to peel off the layers and to try and decipher what needs are being met by this behavior - or by the feeling that I want to do this behavior?

In the example of the Bnei Yisrael, what needs were they lacking at the time? What other ways could they have filled their need?

I don't for one minute think that this clears up the episode. But I hope there is a useful messge there. There are so many questions and I will leave you with a few that I noticed, in the hope that you will suggest something!

1. How is it that the Jews got into this frenzy so fast? And if you will answer the midrash about the Satan making it seem like he was dead, surely it is ridiculous to expect any different if their experience shocked them so deeply?

2. Why did the Jews think that Aaron could make them a G-d, but couldn't be the new intermediary?

3. In 32:14, the famous words we read on fast days 'and Hashem reconsidered regarding the evil that He decleared He would do to the people of Israel. Can G-d do evil?

Hope you have a most fabulous shabbos,

Love

Eli

1 comment: